Quote: 'Butler reads her differently. In her early work, she took the famous line — “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman” — to mean that gender and sex were wholly constructed.'
Butler is apparently too obtuse to recognize metaphor when she sees it.
Honestly, my 12-year-old self would’ve been able to tell you Beauvoir was speaking in metaphor. Why are today’s academics so goddamn stupid??
Yes, I agree and I honestly I don't know what happened. Something to do with the arrogance of post-modernism and its unbelievable disconnection from the reality of life I think. Only 'stupid' people believe in that; the clever, the elect, go along with Butler. For them, there are no limits - words can overcome everything. Especially if you can fathom her foggy, tortuous, elusive sentences - now that's a mark of the elect (apparently...)!
My working hypothesis is that Judith Butler stumbled into a successful combination of obscurantism and pseudo-intellectual support for the BDSM culture of extreme body modification that emerged in California, concurrent with the niche porn explosion of the early public Internet.
Berkeley is a short distance from the start-up capital of San Francisco, where under-socialised male geeks got rich while stealing their mother's underwear for kicks, and paying to be spanked. In turn, the influx of new money from wealthy geeks altered the BDSM scene, as Buck Angel described.
Because porn addiction requires an ever-increasing dose, there were two avenues for the men that built the Internet we know today: get off the computer and into rehab, or double down on their fetishes and seek out a guru that will tell you whatever you're into is perfectly fine and progressive. Judith Butler was in the right place at the right time to be that guru for people who wanted to feel clever about their kink.
A woman and actual lesbian academic appears to be saying that we can all be women if we want! This had so much more credibility than a grubby nerd typing it from the confines of his mother's basement. And so of all the academics that could have been chosen, Butler became platformed as the authoritative new face of feminism despite her work having very little to offer women, once the excitement of infinite gender possibility wore off.
Actual grassroots feminism, of the kind that opposes porn and sexual exploitation, was obscured by this supposed new wave. Platforming Butler, rather than for example Dworkin or Bindel, thereby served dual purposes for the emergent tech economy which was almost entirely funded by porn in the early years.
I believe Butler is a mystic of the Hegelian variety, and that gender transition is sex alchemy; transmuting form without the restraint of physical laws, using esoteric knowledge. Despite the mumbo jumbo, we can't turn base metal into gold, and we can't really turn men into women. But a fool and their money are soon parted, and the gold rush state of California has always been home to cults for this very reason.
I don’t think Beauvoir intended that as a metaphor at all:
People are born female, but do not become women until they mature. Since everybody grows up in a society, the concept “woman” necessarily includes, and cannot be thought of, apart from social constructions. There is no such thing as a woman that isn’t influenced by a society’s concept of womanhood.
This seems quite literally true to me.
That said, I agree Butler’s reading of it is bunk. I’m not sure why the relevance of society to any discussion of adult female experience nullifies the fact of biological difference for Butler. I don’t think Beauvoir is suggesting that any girl who survives to adulthood is not automatically a woman; only that it’s impossible to talk about woman without talking about culture.
I’m lost: by ‘metaphor’ you meant ‘literal’? I am familiar with the common abuse of ‘literally’, but what could have allured you to use metaphor to mean literal, and to accuse academics for not recognizing it?
In that 'becoming' is figurative language for a process of maturation which is not merely biological, as would have been explained in a textbook on puberty of her time, but also social.
If we take the famous quote too literally, it means nothing more than that adulthood follows childhood for female humans. That is true, but doesn't convey any new insight.
See also Sabrina Spielrein's paper of 1912, the title of which was translated as Destruction as the Cause of Coming Into Being. That is also an example of 'becoming', but in a different sense; that of the act of reproduction being a consequence of sacrifice.
In the therapy world symbolic thinking has been replaced by the concrete, so 'as if born in the wrong body,' becomes 'born in the wrong body.' It's a shame, there's so much to be curious about, to explore, towards self-understanding and self-development, but then along comes the affirmation model, validating at the expense of dialogue.
A lot of post modernists are. You can’t believe the crap I heard from an idiot professor—and that was the early 80s. Because I was young and stupid, I took it as fact. It didn’t occur to me to question her because she never explained that her ideas were a theory, not truth.
This essay resonated with me so strongly, reading it felt like hearing my own thoughts spoken out loud. As a childless (by choice), 'CIS' woman, going through menopause, I feel increasingly out of step with a society that seems to value 'gender fluidity' above all else, and at whatever cost. Challenging, thought-provoking, and honest. Thank you.
Written so lucidly; thank you. If the body does not matter why the need for body changing processes? History tells us the body matters and still does matter. Just as an example the use of rape (against men and women) in genocidal wars speaks of the complexities and the messiness of the interplay between the body and identity. Erasing one does not give primacy to the other only to the further 'Othering' of women.
Thank you Sandra. There is a reasoning here that is ideological not logical, isn't there? I think that may explain some of the cognitive dissonance perhaps!
Ah yes! Let’s not forget they/them!I’m sure the girls exposed to trafficking, and women and girls in Afghanistan and across the world appreciate that the trans woman has it far worse- perhaps they should swap places- so they can really feel the fear of being a woman…
Butlers writing is vacuous for me. It hides behind a faux-highbrow intellectual word soup. I find myself needing to read a passage of Doris Lessing or Annie Proulx after fighting through the barbed wire of her prose.
"Today, Simone de Beauvoir is mostly taught through Judith Butler’s lens"
What a horrific tragedy.
I wonder if the climate has changed enough by now for your book to be able to find a publisher? I would hope that there are some publishers who have remembered WTF it is that they are supposed to be doing ...
I can well imagine that it does indeed make you want to cry - as you see it before you in young women who put quotes around the word woman. Imagine conjuring up a such a framing and thinking this is feminism.
When the cultural dominance of the genderborg gets me down, though, I reach for the rush of energy and the sense of adventure I can still conjure up - from when at 15 the truth of second wave feminism hit me. I That free-wheeling energy, uncluttered by bonkers regressive belief that female somehow not being real, or important, or that acknowledging I am female equates to “being defined by” being female.
Just spot on and powerful. I always think if transwomen were really women they could never be doing what that are to biolgical women. They have zero feeling compasion or understanding. Just like the majority of err Men! They have no idea what it is to be a woman. Whether young or old a mother or childless, in menopause or just facing puberty. Woman is a lived body experience all our lives.
A good counter to the statement that “cis” people “created” sex for whatever reason is that sex is over a billion years old, and its definition applies to far more than just humans. Something over a billion years old cannot have been “created” by a species only 200-300 thousand years old. Once that is made clear, it’s easier to see that the “what is a woman” question is the philosophical intersection between biological fact and culture.
Why do I as a woman need Butler or any other author to tell me what a woman is or how a woman’s identity is developed? I’ve always gone my own way and quite frankly resented others’ attempts to categorize me. But while I am grateful for any author who will speak against Judith Butler, I am wary of anyone trying to interpret de Beauvoir as I find her words to be clear enough and even she could only explain her own perceptions.
I agree. What I think is important is bringing Beauvoir's own words back, instead of receiving them through the lens of Butler or others. That's really what my project is about in a nutshell.
Thank you so much! I am always infuriated when (usually young) feminists misunderstand de Beauvoir. I can't see how they can; perhaps because they aren't getting a good enough feminist history before they read de Beauvoir? They certainly need to learn 2500 year of thinking by and about women to equip them to read Butler.
They are primed by certain men's wishful thinking. If one is not born a woman, because one was born a man, then man can 'become' woman, so their delusion goes.
Well, modern 'sexology' is all German. Even native English-speaking sexologists like Havelock Ellis published in German first.
While some Americans may choose to undergo gender transition to prove that they are free to do whatever they want, I believe the underlying ideology is that reason creates reality, which comes from German idealism. If you think you're a woman, you are one. Judith Butler's PhD thesis was about Hegelian influences on French thought.
Hi Daniel. I have nothing against sexology per se. And this may be a slight exaggeration, but aren’t modern physics and chemistry pretty much German as well?! Moreover, I wouldn’t tar all German Romanticism with the same brush. After all, facticity comes from Fichte, and is central to Schelling’s critique of Hegel which in turn influenced Heidegger and then of course Sartre and DeBeauvoir (which is where this started!). On the other hand, I’m a card carrying pragmatist, a tradition heavily influenced by Hegel. And there are other interpretations of Hegel that are not “idealist” in the sense you presumably intend. After all, the facts relating to sex aren’t unmediated/brute or nonrational or “un-pre-thinkable” in the Fichtean sense. Indeed, that better characterises the attachment to unmediated “identity”! It’s the gender absolutists that have abandoned (Hegelian? Why not?!) Reason, not us! That takes us back to the weird Buttler way of reading Hegel though the lens of French theory.
Thanks for the reply; you sound much better versed in the subject than my shallow reading has afforded. I don't think the problem with sexology is that it is German, but that it comes from that paradigm of speculation taken seriously which certain Germans have specialised in. It's all theory despite evidence, which has serious repercussions when it escapes the printed page and impinges on the real world.
The postmodern twist means that its advocates are allergic to consistency. For example, they will argue that gender transition is a human right under the principle of bodily autonomy, and simultaneously argue for public funding for that transition on the basis that society owes it to them. So, are they autonomous or not? Or do they inhabit a responsibility-free autonomy which only has moral obligations in one direction? And if so, is it a philosophy, or just opportunism?
My take is that bodily autonomy is a social construct in which only certain actions are supported and funded. If you are gender non-conforming and want to destroy your fertility, that is considered a valid choice and so public funding is available. If you want to use the same amount of funding for another purpose, that money is not available. And so the exercise of 'autonomy' is in fact the pre-directed choice of a third party.
Hi Daniel. I'm yet to take a deep dive into Hirschfeld et al, though I've read perhaps more than I needed to of Blanchard's work. But I got into this from a conceptual/philosophical angle so my focus has been on the coherence of the central concept of gender identity. If it were coherent, and if replacing biological distinctions with "identity" based categories (gender, broadly) were in some broad sense societally advantageous I'd have no objection to the change. But it isn't coherent and the "cost" for replacing biological distinctions is enormous and as usual expected to be born by women (and vulnerable young people) in particular. So questions about resource allocation come further down the pipeline for me. I doubt we disagree on much on this topic, but I would avoid talk of "social construct" in this area. It suggests a binary opposition between that which is and that which isn't "constructed" that invites metaphysical speculation! So the Hegelian-pragmatist in me prefers talk of societal norms: things we can argue for and against in a relatively philosophically neutral way. So personal autonomy has socially sanctioned and negotiated limits that are answerable to evidence. But the gender absolutist refuses to engage in that process of negotiation (of the public use of reason) because they are attached to something that is not answerable to public scrutiny: their self-ascribed identity. So we must remind people who can be swayed of the "cost" of believing in such a thing to other people (women; homosexuals; confused adolescents etc.).
Love it. And I take your point here - “I think of the detransitioners: women who took testosterone, had mastectomies, even hysterectomies, only to realise their real struggle was with embodiment itself.”
But - is embodiment the struggle? Or patriarchy? Seems to me our bodies would be just terrific without the oppression part.
I think you’ve zoned in exactly on the tension Beauvoir is trying to get at here. The experience of inhabiting a body is both social and biological. So girls struggle with puberty not just because growing breasts is strange and uncomfortable for many physically (which it is) but also, and perhaps far more importantly, because men start to stare at you, turn you into an object etc. Beauvoir comes under a lot of criticism for saying it, but her view is that the body itself isn’t easy for women. Some very early feminists I seem to remember think that beyond patriarchy, once all that oppression is over, periods themselves will hardly register - they’ll be mild and painless. I’m not so sure. And Beauvoir never speculates about that. But it’s a very interesting point. And then contrast Andrea Chu’s pro-puberty blocker view. Chu has argued that if children cannot consent to puberty blockers, then they cannot consent to puberty itself. But what’s at stake here that Chu entirely dismisses is the capacity to inhabit a body, to come to terms with its rhythms and reality. Society needs to help young women do that, not encourage them to flee womanhood all together…. Sorry for the very long answer, but it’s a fascinating point that you made. Thanks!
I’m back in academia, having exited after I failed to get a First and thus Master’s funding in my early 20s. I’m reading Butler, of course, but also trying to connect to the dots between what I studied in my BA and what is current academic orthodoxy; between the culture of the mid-90s and now.
I was quite quickly grateful for getting 69 rather than 70% in my undergrad as it meant I could not continue on the trajectory of ignoring my body in favour of developing my intellect. After the initial disappointment I went off and took a lot of ecstasy, dancing in fields as the sun came up with thousands of other young folk, before taking up yoga and having three children. It struck me a few years ago that this trajectory has been an embodied one, for which I am extremely grateful. A life of the mind is a half life, in my opinion.
Anyway, what I wanted to say in response to your comment is that the argument (perhaps that should be in scare quotes) that children cannot consent to puberty is exactly why my critical theory BA broke my brain, and not in a good way. It’s very possible to get lost and confused by the mind, and to lose touch with reality or to argue against it from a totally illogical position that, as mind-generated, appears extremely clever and sophisticated. Susan, you make the point earlier that postmodernism and by inference critical theory is arrogant and disconnected, and the idea that a child cannot consent to puberty epitomises that. What a frankly flabbergastingly stupid argument. None of us necessarily consent to the sun rising every morning, to death or to any of the other givens of which puberty is absolutely one. The idea that the answer is to battle against immutable fact rather than to find ways of working with it - for all of our benefits - seems to be the central issue here. And a failure to accept reality in all its conundrums and messes is exactly what denying the reality of the body is. It’s no coincidence, in my opinion, that we’re at this point re the sexed body at the same time as ecological meltdown and the rise of AI.
I'm so glad to have found your work Susan. As a long retired clinical social worker I find it jarring and a bit disorienting to realize that I would no doubt be drummed out of my profession in today's barking mad climate of "gender ideology trumps material reality." It all somehow has the feel of some irrational mass contagion medieval end-times cult - "Judith Butler meets Saint Vitus Dance" - or the like. That you could not find an academic publisher harkens back to the thought control efforts entailed in the Vatican's "list of banned books." Thank you for your work and your courage to stand by it.
Quote: 'Butler reads her differently. In her early work, she took the famous line — “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman” — to mean that gender and sex were wholly constructed.'
Butler is apparently too obtuse to recognize metaphor when she sees it.
Honestly, my 12-year-old self would’ve been able to tell you Beauvoir was speaking in metaphor. Why are today’s academics so goddamn stupid??
Yes, I agree and I honestly I don't know what happened. Something to do with the arrogance of post-modernism and its unbelievable disconnection from the reality of life I think. Only 'stupid' people believe in that; the clever, the elect, go along with Butler. For them, there are no limits - words can overcome everything. Especially if you can fathom her foggy, tortuous, elusive sentences - now that's a mark of the elect (apparently...)!
My working hypothesis is that Judith Butler stumbled into a successful combination of obscurantism and pseudo-intellectual support for the BDSM culture of extreme body modification that emerged in California, concurrent with the niche porn explosion of the early public Internet.
Berkeley is a short distance from the start-up capital of San Francisco, where under-socialised male geeks got rich while stealing their mother's underwear for kicks, and paying to be spanked. In turn, the influx of new money from wealthy geeks altered the BDSM scene, as Buck Angel described.
Because porn addiction requires an ever-increasing dose, there were two avenues for the men that built the Internet we know today: get off the computer and into rehab, or double down on their fetishes and seek out a guru that will tell you whatever you're into is perfectly fine and progressive. Judith Butler was in the right place at the right time to be that guru for people who wanted to feel clever about their kink.
A woman and actual lesbian academic appears to be saying that we can all be women if we want! This had so much more credibility than a grubby nerd typing it from the confines of his mother's basement. And so of all the academics that could have been chosen, Butler became platformed as the authoritative new face of feminism despite her work having very little to offer women, once the excitement of infinite gender possibility wore off.
Actual grassroots feminism, of the kind that opposes porn and sexual exploitation, was obscured by this supposed new wave. Platforming Butler, rather than for example Dworkin or Bindel, thereby served dual purposes for the emergent tech economy which was almost entirely funded by porn in the early years.
I believe Butler is a mystic of the Hegelian variety, and that gender transition is sex alchemy; transmuting form without the restraint of physical laws, using esoteric knowledge. Despite the mumbo jumbo, we can't turn base metal into gold, and we can't really turn men into women. But a fool and their money are soon parted, and the gold rush state of California has always been home to cults for this very reason.
So well put, Daniel, especially that last paragraph!
I don’t think Beauvoir intended that as a metaphor at all:
People are born female, but do not become women until they mature. Since everybody grows up in a society, the concept “woman” necessarily includes, and cannot be thought of, apart from social constructions. There is no such thing as a woman that isn’t influenced by a society’s concept of womanhood.
This seems quite literally true to me.
That said, I agree Butler’s reading of it is bunk. I’m not sure why the relevance of society to any discussion of adult female experience nullifies the fact of biological difference for Butler. I don’t think Beauvoir is suggesting that any girl who survives to adulthood is not automatically a woman; only that it’s impossible to talk about woman without talking about culture.
wildflux, I agree. That's actually what I meant by metaphor.
I’m lost: by ‘metaphor’ you meant ‘literal’? I am familiar with the common abuse of ‘literally’, but what could have allured you to use metaphor to mean literal, and to accuse academics for not recognizing it?
In that 'becoming' is figurative language for a process of maturation which is not merely biological, as would have been explained in a textbook on puberty of her time, but also social.
If we take the famous quote too literally, it means nothing more than that adulthood follows childhood for female humans. That is true, but doesn't convey any new insight.
See also Sabrina Spielrein's paper of 1912, the title of which was translated as Destruction as the Cause of Coming Into Being. That is also an example of 'becoming', but in a different sense; that of the act of reproduction being a consequence of sacrifice.
In the therapy world symbolic thinking has been replaced by the concrete, so 'as if born in the wrong body,' becomes 'born in the wrong body.' It's a shame, there's so much to be curious about, to explore, towards self-understanding and self-development, but then along comes the affirmation model, validating at the expense of dialogue.
A lot of post modernists are. You can’t believe the crap I heard from an idiot professor—and that was the early 80s. Because I was young and stupid, I took it as fact. It didn’t occur to me to question her because she never explained that her ideas were a theory, not truth.
Is there a generational divide with Beauvoirists on one side and Butlerists on the other?
No, I wish it were true but I don’t think so. Not in the academy.
Sure looks that way to me.
Where is the metaphor? What is being taken for what?
This essay resonated with me so strongly, reading it felt like hearing my own thoughts spoken out loud. As a childless (by choice), 'CIS' woman, going through menopause, I feel increasingly out of step with a society that seems to value 'gender fluidity' above all else, and at whatever cost. Challenging, thought-provoking, and honest. Thank you.
Jayne, really pleased it resonated. It is beyond believable that anyone other than the young and totally naive would buy into this, isn't it?
It really is, Susan.
Written so lucidly; thank you. If the body does not matter why the need for body changing processes? History tells us the body matters and still does matter. Just as an example the use of rape (against men and women) in genocidal wars speaks of the complexities and the messiness of the interplay between the body and identity. Erasing one does not give primacy to the other only to the further 'Othering' of women.
Thank you Sandra. There is a reasoning here that is ideological not logical, isn't there? I think that may explain some of the cognitive dissonance perhaps!
Indeed.......I like your optimism that these tensions maybe a result of cognitive dissonance.....
So interesting- and something gender ideological daughters and women need to consider- if women are not real then why are they being persecuted?
That's a great point!
“Oh but the most persecuted are transwomen” - suicide, murder, etc. I’ve heard that so many times from women who are not thinking.
Ah yes! Let’s not forget they/them!I’m sure the girls exposed to trafficking, and women and girls in Afghanistan and across the world appreciate that the trans woman has it far worse- perhaps they should swap places- so they can really feel the fear of being a woman…
Butlers writing is vacuous for me. It hides behind a faux-highbrow intellectual word soup. I find myself needing to read a passage of Doris Lessing or Annie Proulx after fighting through the barbed wire of her prose.
Yours, on the other hand, is a wave I surf on.
"Today, Simone de Beauvoir is mostly taught through Judith Butler’s lens"
What a horrific tragedy.
I wonder if the climate has changed enough by now for your book to be able to find a publisher? I would hope that there are some publishers who have remembered WTF it is that they are supposed to be doing ...
Thank you. This moved me to tears. Like the joy of discovering second wave feminism all over again.
Dr T - I'm with you on that one. Sometimes the idea that second wave feminism has been discarded makes me want to cry.
I can well imagine that it does indeed make you want to cry - as you see it before you in young women who put quotes around the word woman. Imagine conjuring up a such a framing and thinking this is feminism.
When the cultural dominance of the genderborg gets me down, though, I reach for the rush of energy and the sense of adventure I can still conjure up - from when at 15 the truth of second wave feminism hit me. I That free-wheeling energy, uncluttered by bonkers regressive belief that female somehow not being real, or important, or that acknowledging I am female equates to “being defined by” being female.
Just spot on and powerful. I always think if transwomen were really women they could never be doing what that are to biolgical women. They have zero feeling compasion or understanding. Just like the majority of err Men! They have no idea what it is to be a woman. Whether young or old a mother or childless, in menopause or just facing puberty. Woman is a lived body experience all our lives.
Brilliant piece. This is explained really well in such a principled and thoughtful way.
Thank you Shibley, this is hugely appreciated
A good counter to the statement that “cis” people “created” sex for whatever reason is that sex is over a billion years old, and its definition applies to far more than just humans. Something over a billion years old cannot have been “created” by a species only 200-300 thousand years old. Once that is made clear, it’s easier to see that the “what is a woman” question is the philosophical intersection between biological fact and culture.
Why do I as a woman need Butler or any other author to tell me what a woman is or how a woman’s identity is developed? I’ve always gone my own way and quite frankly resented others’ attempts to categorize me. But while I am grateful for any author who will speak against Judith Butler, I am wary of anyone trying to interpret de Beauvoir as I find her words to be clear enough and even she could only explain her own perceptions.
I agree. What I think is important is bringing Beauvoir's own words back, instead of receiving them through the lens of Butler or others. That's really what my project is about in a nutshell.
Thank you so much! I am always infuriated when (usually young) feminists misunderstand de Beauvoir. I can't see how they can; perhaps because they aren't getting a good enough feminist history before they read de Beauvoir? They certainly need to learn 2500 year of thinking by and about women to equip them to read Butler.
They are primed by certain men's wishful thinking. If one is not born a woman, because one was born a man, then man can 'become' woman, so their delusion goes.
I wonder if this neglect of facticity is due to a peculiarly American understanding of the meaning of freedom?
Well, modern 'sexology' is all German. Even native English-speaking sexologists like Havelock Ellis published in German first.
While some Americans may choose to undergo gender transition to prove that they are free to do whatever they want, I believe the underlying ideology is that reason creates reality, which comes from German idealism. If you think you're a woman, you are one. Judith Butler's PhD thesis was about Hegelian influences on French thought.
Hi Daniel. I have nothing against sexology per se. And this may be a slight exaggeration, but aren’t modern physics and chemistry pretty much German as well?! Moreover, I wouldn’t tar all German Romanticism with the same brush. After all, facticity comes from Fichte, and is central to Schelling’s critique of Hegel which in turn influenced Heidegger and then of course Sartre and DeBeauvoir (which is where this started!). On the other hand, I’m a card carrying pragmatist, a tradition heavily influenced by Hegel. And there are other interpretations of Hegel that are not “idealist” in the sense you presumably intend. After all, the facts relating to sex aren’t unmediated/brute or nonrational or “un-pre-thinkable” in the Fichtean sense. Indeed, that better characterises the attachment to unmediated “identity”! It’s the gender absolutists that have abandoned (Hegelian? Why not?!) Reason, not us! That takes us back to the weird Buttler way of reading Hegel though the lens of French theory.
Thanks for the reply; you sound much better versed in the subject than my shallow reading has afforded. I don't think the problem with sexology is that it is German, but that it comes from that paradigm of speculation taken seriously which certain Germans have specialised in. It's all theory despite evidence, which has serious repercussions when it escapes the printed page and impinges on the real world.
The postmodern twist means that its advocates are allergic to consistency. For example, they will argue that gender transition is a human right under the principle of bodily autonomy, and simultaneously argue for public funding for that transition on the basis that society owes it to them. So, are they autonomous or not? Or do they inhabit a responsibility-free autonomy which only has moral obligations in one direction? And if so, is it a philosophy, or just opportunism?
My take is that bodily autonomy is a social construct in which only certain actions are supported and funded. If you are gender non-conforming and want to destroy your fertility, that is considered a valid choice and so public funding is available. If you want to use the same amount of funding for another purpose, that money is not available. And so the exercise of 'autonomy' is in fact the pre-directed choice of a third party.
Hi Daniel. I'm yet to take a deep dive into Hirschfeld et al, though I've read perhaps more than I needed to of Blanchard's work. But I got into this from a conceptual/philosophical angle so my focus has been on the coherence of the central concept of gender identity. If it were coherent, and if replacing biological distinctions with "identity" based categories (gender, broadly) were in some broad sense societally advantageous I'd have no objection to the change. But it isn't coherent and the "cost" for replacing biological distinctions is enormous and as usual expected to be born by women (and vulnerable young people) in particular. So questions about resource allocation come further down the pipeline for me. I doubt we disagree on much on this topic, but I would avoid talk of "social construct" in this area. It suggests a binary opposition between that which is and that which isn't "constructed" that invites metaphysical speculation! So the Hegelian-pragmatist in me prefers talk of societal norms: things we can argue for and against in a relatively philosophically neutral way. So personal autonomy has socially sanctioned and negotiated limits that are answerable to evidence. But the gender absolutist refuses to engage in that process of negotiation (of the public use of reason) because they are attached to something that is not answerable to public scrutiny: their self-ascribed identity. So we must remind people who can be swayed of the "cost" of believing in such a thing to other people (women; homosexuals; confused adolescents etc.).
Would be amazing to publish your whole book somewhere still and make it available, (like a pdf, for offline reading) not just in substack 😭❤️🙏
Love it. And I take your point here - “I think of the detransitioners: women who took testosterone, had mastectomies, even hysterectomies, only to realise their real struggle was with embodiment itself.”
But - is embodiment the struggle? Or patriarchy? Seems to me our bodies would be just terrific without the oppression part.
I think you’ve zoned in exactly on the tension Beauvoir is trying to get at here. The experience of inhabiting a body is both social and biological. So girls struggle with puberty not just because growing breasts is strange and uncomfortable for many physically (which it is) but also, and perhaps far more importantly, because men start to stare at you, turn you into an object etc. Beauvoir comes under a lot of criticism for saying it, but her view is that the body itself isn’t easy for women. Some very early feminists I seem to remember think that beyond patriarchy, once all that oppression is over, periods themselves will hardly register - they’ll be mild and painless. I’m not so sure. And Beauvoir never speculates about that. But it’s a very interesting point. And then contrast Andrea Chu’s pro-puberty blocker view. Chu has argued that if children cannot consent to puberty blockers, then they cannot consent to puberty itself. But what’s at stake here that Chu entirely dismisses is the capacity to inhabit a body, to come to terms with its rhythms and reality. Society needs to help young women do that, not encourage them to flee womanhood all together…. Sorry for the very long answer, but it’s a fascinating point that you made. Thanks!
I’m back in academia, having exited after I failed to get a First and thus Master’s funding in my early 20s. I’m reading Butler, of course, but also trying to connect to the dots between what I studied in my BA and what is current academic orthodoxy; between the culture of the mid-90s and now.
I was quite quickly grateful for getting 69 rather than 70% in my undergrad as it meant I could not continue on the trajectory of ignoring my body in favour of developing my intellect. After the initial disappointment I went off and took a lot of ecstasy, dancing in fields as the sun came up with thousands of other young folk, before taking up yoga and having three children. It struck me a few years ago that this trajectory has been an embodied one, for which I am extremely grateful. A life of the mind is a half life, in my opinion.
Anyway, what I wanted to say in response to your comment is that the argument (perhaps that should be in scare quotes) that children cannot consent to puberty is exactly why my critical theory BA broke my brain, and not in a good way. It’s very possible to get lost and confused by the mind, and to lose touch with reality or to argue against it from a totally illogical position that, as mind-generated, appears extremely clever and sophisticated. Susan, you make the point earlier that postmodernism and by inference critical theory is arrogant and disconnected, and the idea that a child cannot consent to puberty epitomises that. What a frankly flabbergastingly stupid argument. None of us necessarily consent to the sun rising every morning, to death or to any of the other givens of which puberty is absolutely one. The idea that the answer is to battle against immutable fact rather than to find ways of working with it - for all of our benefits - seems to be the central issue here. And a failure to accept reality in all its conundrums and messes is exactly what denying the reality of the body is. It’s no coincidence, in my opinion, that we’re at this point re the sexed body at the same time as ecological meltdown and the rise of AI.
I'm so glad to have found your work Susan. As a long retired clinical social worker I find it jarring and a bit disorienting to realize that I would no doubt be drummed out of my profession in today's barking mad climate of "gender ideology trumps material reality." It all somehow has the feel of some irrational mass contagion medieval end-times cult - "Judith Butler meets Saint Vitus Dance" - or the like. That you could not find an academic publisher harkens back to the thought control efforts entailed in the Vatican's "list of banned books." Thank you for your work and your courage to stand by it.